Canada’s meeting place for freelance writers and creators

Established 2010

Even if you don't know his name, if you're interested in the media, you've read Jim Romenesko's work. For 12 years he's written about media goings-on for Poynter.org, but last night he ended their relationship. And for good reason, say many other members of the online media.

Poynter Online director Julie Moos wrote a post that said "Romenesko’s posts exhibit a pattern of incomplete attribution." What she meant was: he sometimes doesn't put quotation marks around text that comes from other sources, which goes against Poynter's publishing practices and standards. She continues:

"Effective immediately, Jim’s work for Poynter will change in a few important respects. First, it will follow our standards of attribution. Second, it will be edited before it is published. I asked Jim Wednesday night to refrain from publishing while we sorted out this situation, and he has done so. Jim has offered to resign and I refused to accept his resignation. In August, Jim announced his plan to semi-retire at the end of this year."

She posted this on Romenesko's blog. From the tweet above, Romenesko's next offer to resign must have stuck.

Moos' allegation is not false, but the context in which Romenesko writes, often summarizing (and linking to) other media news stories, may excuse it. He was writing for an incredibly media-literate readership, after all. Maybe they didn't need those quotation marks. And it seems that the people whose work Romenesko was aggregating didn't need them either. Moos notes in her post, no writers had ever contacted Poynter to complain about his attribution style.

This isn't the end of Romenesko's media-watching career, though. He says will blog on his own site, JimRomenesko.com, about media issues, as well as other favourite topics, like food and finance.

What do you think of Romenesko's attribution, or lack thereof? Did the context in which he was writing excuse it? Or was he getting away with something he shouldn't because of his clout with the media? Would you complain if your work was used in a similar context? Comment and let us know.

Read more:

"Romenesko resigns after 12 years at Poynter" [Julie Moos' latest post on Poynter's Romenesko+ blog]

"Jim Romenesko’s departure sparks strong reaction, criticism" [Another reaction post on Romenesko+]

"The Preposterous Plagiarism Assault on Romenesko" [Gawker]

"The Intolerable Evolution of Poynter's 'Romenesko+'" [The Awl]

"No Way to Treat a Romenesko" [American Journalism Review]

"Jim Romenesko Leaves Poynter - And the blogosphere cries foul" [Columbia Journalism Review]

"Romenesko Leaves Poynter After Conflict Over Quotes" [NYTimes Media Decoder]

I was having coffee recently with a colleague.Okay, actually, in my case, it was hot chocolate. Hey, it was cold outside and I needed a sugar hit. But we freelancers haven't yet come up with a better expression than "having coffee" to denote a casual meeting. "Having tea" sounds too lightweight. "Having hot chocolate" sounds too juvenile. "Having…
What is a journalist? What is a journalistic act? What's the best way to protect the rights of journalists? Can we trust journalists to identify and monitor one another?This Saturday evening, about 50 journalists and people concerned about the state of journalism today packed into the Upper Library at U of T's Massey College and discussed these and…
The Registered Graphic Designers of Ontario are wrapping up their Design Thinkers conference today, and the Canadian Writers Group helped make it another successful industry event. As the RGD's official content sponsor, CWG contributed heavily to the conference's materials. The agency's writers had a big hand in crafting the Design Thinkers blog…
Watch out Amazon and Kobo, Google wants its slice of Canada's ebook retail market.Google's eBookstore is now open to Canadian customers, offering hundreds of thousands of books for sale and upwards of 2 million free public-domain titles. Google has already struck deals with Canadian publishers big (Penguin, Random House, and Harper Collins) and…
Work more.That's the advice Krystal Yee shared in a recent Moneyville.ca post. Over the course of 2011, she has boosted her income by 50 per cent by adding 20-30 hours per week of part-time and freelance work on top of her full-time job. She took on two part-time writing gigs, freelance graphic design work, and she wrote on her own blog (earning…
Kindle Direct Publishing has quickly become a popular platform for authors to promote and sell their own work. Whether it's used to publish full-length books or Singles, KDP lets authors bypass traditional publishing channels and market their writing directly, up to and including setting their own prices. But in KDP's fine print is a clause that…
The group Investigative Reporters & Editors, partnering with the Ryerson University School of Journalism and the Canadian Association of Journalists Educational Foundation, is bringing its Better Watchdog Workshop to Toronto. Sponsored by the Toronto Star, the two-day workshop will focus on investigative journalism skills, including tips on online…
Canadian author alleges publisher and U.K. writer stole idea for children's book [caption id="attachment_2093" align="alignnone" width="580" caption="Covers of the book published by Scholastic (left) and Carruthers' self-published book."][/caption]We recently shared the story of a freelancer who suspected a profile idea she had pitched was…
If it worked for the Huffington Post, why can't it work for Food & Drink Digital? The latter publication's public relations manager, Jeremy Vara, is sending a message to potential contributor that asks for them to share their expertise with Food & Drink Digital's "exclusive audience." Jim Romenesko posted the email he received from Vara in full on…

Page 142 of 159

First 140 141 142 143 144 Last